Skip to main content

Movie Critic Review: The Shining (1980) Part Two

Kubrick-King: A Creative Conflict
"Londrina, Brazil --(SBWIRE) 02/01/2012--
The Shining Code is releasing a one-hour documentary which deciphers and explains the meaning behind Stanley Kubrick's The Shining. Due to its mysterious nature, the movie left most viewers confused and unable to understand what the events that took place were all about. The Shining Code documentary unlocks more than 50 codes within the film, codes that finally shed some light on the mysteries that left so many scratching their head and wondering what possessed Kubrick to put forth such a film."  from SBWire.com
------------------

"I couldn't even make it through the whole movie, I didn't like it at all. It felt kitchy and didn't scare me at all as always." Writer one. 
---------------------
"The movie stinks. BAD. It barely even relegates to the novel for the most part! The book is on" Writer Two
-------------------

"I am a huge Kubrick fan. I love all his films, and while Full Metal Jacket is my #1 Kubrick, Shining is close behind. I'm a big Stephen King fan too, and while I haven't yet read the novel, I plan doing so soon. However, I think what's important here is that like all his other adaptations, Kubrick used the story as a jumping off point to tell a much larger story. The Shining could be Kubrick's most dense film in terms of themes; there's just so much going on, so many ways it can be interpreted. Is it a story about the emasculation and rage of the American male? Is it about the slaughter of the Native Americans, or indigenous people in general by "civilized" alien forces? Is it about a father who goes nuts due to cabin fever? It works as all those things. I think Kubrick was attracted to the project first because it... allowed a huge investigation as to what would drive a man to kill his wife and son. That's a really tough subject, and as always, Kubrick didn't have the answers, he just wanted to explore it. So, I get why King disliked it. He was too close to it, he loved his creation, as he should. It must've been tough to see someone (in a sense) devalue his intention with something else. But that doesn't diminish the power of the film. I'd say give it another chance. Divorce your expectations from an adaptation of a King novel. Think of it as a continuing exploration of humanity that started with Dr. Strangelove and ended with Eyes Wide Shut." Writer Three.
------------------

Stanley Kubrick
"..The Shining didn't originate from any particular desire to do a film about the (paranormal)" said Kubrick to his interviewer Michel Ciment.
He went on to elaborate on his conversion of Stephen King's novel "The Shining" into
a movie: "I thought it was one of the most ingenious and exciting stories of the genre
I had read. It seemed to strike an extraordinary balance between the psychological and
the supernatural in such a way as to lead you to think that the supernatural would eventually be explained by the psychological: Jack must be imagining these things because he's crazy. This allowed you to suspend your doubt of the supernatural until you were so thoroughly
into the story that you could accept it almost without noticing."  End of qoute from Ciment's
interview.

===

When Kubrick contacted him regarding the making of a movie based on his novel, Stephen King was flattered. As the story goes, Kubrick explained to King how ghost stories are optimistic, as they suggest humans actually survive death in a sense. He was referring to his own perspective of the novel "The Shining". King offered to write the screenplay himself but Kubrick did not approve of this. He had other thoughts. I would have too, if I were a movie-maker of Kubrick's intellectual caliber!
"I think, in some ways, the conventions of realistic fiction and drama may impose serious limitations on a story. For one thing, if you play by the rules and respect the preparation and pace required to establish realism, it takes a lot longer to make a point than it does, say, in fantasy. At the same time, it is possible that this very work that contributes to a story's realism may weaken its grip on the unconscious. Realism is probably the best way to dramatize argument and ideas. Fantasy may deal best with themes which lie primarily in the unconscious. I think the unconscious appeal of a ghost story, for instance, lies in its promise of immortality. If you can be frightened by a ghost story, then you must accept the possibility that supernatural beings exist. If they do, then there is more than just oblivion waiting beyond the grave." said Kubrick to interviewer Joseph Gelmis.

====

Kubrick went on to contact another less-known novelist Diane Johnson to co-write
the screenplay for King's novel. Kubrick got 'interested in Johnson because he learnt that she was giving a course at the University of California at Berkeley on the Gothic novel and could bring a scholarly knowledge of literary horror to the script'. He thought she was 'the ideal collaborator for The Shining.' On the other hand, health issues related to King would have slowed the work on the movie. Kubrick was known to be a very strict and  committed person who demands dedication and hard work from people working with him.
Despite all this research and effort done by Stanley Kubrick to lay his own vision of a literary work, Stephen King, the originator of the work, did not like Kubrick's adaptation of his novel.
Here is what he had to say as a comment on Kubrick's adaptation of The Shining:
"The real problem is that Kubrick set out to make a horror picture with no apparent understanding of the genre. Everything about it screams that from beginning to end, from plot decision to the final scene - which has been used before on the Twilight Zone."
King went on to complain that "Kubrick has changed Jack Torrance from a good man destroyed by alcoholism into someone who was bad from the start."
This very work of Kubrick was regarded by Newsweek as "The first epic horror movie!"

 ==

David Kirkpatrick writes that one characteristic of epics is the encyclopedic scope.
He then goes on to cite ways in which the movie The Shining can be seen as an "encyclopedia" of horror themes. 
He examines entities such as ghost, haunted house, Dr. Jeckyll and Mr. Hyde, werewolf, Frankenstein, witchcraft, vampires, the Devil, Oedipus, the psychopath. He finds embodiment, evidences, links or references to all of these in Kubrick's adaptation.
One must admit, though, that the changes were significant!
In the novel Danny could actually see Toni, the person who resides in his mouth. In the movie Toni is only in his head.
It is the (imagined) Toni that does not like the idea of going to the hotel whereas in the novel Danny says yes to going to the hotel.
In the novel Wendy never reads what Jack is typing but in the movie she reads that single sentence Jack kept typing over and over again for days:
(All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy)!
In the novel, the chef, Dick Halloran lives to save Danny and his mother and the hotel Outlook is destroyed. And many more differences.

Writes one critic: "Kubrick diplomatically claimed that the technology didn’t exist to make

the hedge animals' work, but since this was the man who revolutionized visual effects in 2001: A Space Odyssey, the filmmaker most likely wrote the hedge animals off as lame

and unnecessary. Instead, an immense hedge maze was constructed (it was so big that even crew members would reportedly get themselves lost at times). Is it meant as a metaphor, reflecting Jack Torrance’s disintegrating mental state? The shot of a clearly

half-mad Jack staring into the hedge maze’s model as his family is outside wandering through seems to reinforce this idea."

Indeed this was one of the best scenes!
But Kubrick remains faithful to pivotal parts of the novel such as the "scene of Jack Torrance’s first real break with reality in the famous ballroom sequence. Pissed off at

his wife, Jack wanders in and sits at the deserted bar, wishing for a drink. He looks up

and begins a batshit-crazy monologue to an imaginary barkeep named Lloyd… and then, suddenly, Lloyd is there. Every word of this scene is nearly verbatim from the book,

including Jack’s later exchange with Grady, after Jack looks around

to discover a flapper-era masquerade party in full swing."

The final scene which leaves one scratching his head for answers is non-existent in
the novel and is one of Kubrick's puzzles as explained in part one of this review.
"Stephen King had the chance to "do everything different" with the I997 TV movie

adaptation of The Shining which he wrote and produced. However the TV Shining was poorly received and generally considered to be vastly inferior to the Kubrick's version"!
- - - - -
- - - - - - -

And for over three decades "The Shining" keeps shining!
Our third part will review some of the weirdest interpretations and decoding of the movie.
Go see it! Those who think it is not a horror movie: let me tell you that re-watching it will secure you a night of cold terror. But you will also get to figure out the codes or become a lunatic!

Browse the Amazon products below:

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

جليد نساي - 3/3

جليد نساي (3/3) قراءة في رواية الرجل الخراب عبد العزيز بركة ساكن الجزء الثالث
مصطفى مدثر



سنتناول في هذا الجزء مسألة استلهام ساكن للهدمية الطاغية في قصيدة إليوت وأنه، أي ساكن، لم يشأ لهدمه نهاية أو حل. وكذلك نتناول مسألة البلبلة التي يحدثها استلهامه الآخر المتمثل في تبديل اسم الرواية، ونقترح سبباً لإختيار ساكن أن يكون درويش طبيباً صيدلانياً، كما نناقش التجريب في الرواية وأزمة النهاية. فإلى الجزء الأخير من المقال. أبدأ ببعض الأفكار حول اسم الرواية. إن الإرث الدلالي لكلمة الخراب في عنوان الرواية يبدو كافياً لقبول اسمها، الرجل الخراب، ولكن عندما نعرف من الرواية أن اسمها الحالي كان قد خضع لعملية تغيير مرتين فإننا نرى أن توسيع دائرة الفحص الدلالي قد يعيننا إلى فهم أحسن للأصول الابداعية للرواية. فاسم الرواية تحوّل تحوّلاً محكياً عنه من أزهار الليل إلى مُخرّي الكلاب واستقر عند الرجل الخراب. وقصيدة اليوت نفسها تحوّل اسمها، ربما مرة واحدة، ليستقر على الأرض الخراب. وهذا استلهام آخر للقصيدة نرصده هنا ولا ندعي الحصر. إن المقصود هنا أن هنالك تعارضاً في دلالة الخراب في الاسمين. فبغض النظر عن كون القصيدة تع…

1/3 جليد نسّاي

1/3 جليد نسّاي
قراءة في رواية الرجل الخراب

عبد العزيز بركة ساكن

الجزء الأول


أيها القارئ المرائي، يا شبيهي، يا أخي - بودلير، شاعر فرنسي الفكرة الرئيسة [عند إليوت] هي أننا، حتى ونحن ملزمون بأن نعي ماضوية الماضي..، لا نملك طريقة عادلة لحجر الماضي عن الحاضر. إن الماضي والحاضر متفاعمان، كلٌ يشي بالآخر ويوحي به، وبالمعنى المثالي كلياً الذي ينتويه إليوت ، فإن كلاً منهما يتعايش مع الآخر. ما يقترحه ت س  إليوت بإيجاز هو رؤيا للتراث الأدبي لا يوجهها كلياً التعاقب الزمني، رغم أنها تحترم هذا التعاقب. لا الماضي ولا الحاضر، ولا أي شاعر أو فنان، يملك معنىً كاملاً منفرداً- إدوارد سعيد، استاذ الأدب الإنجليزي الطريق إلى الحقيقة يمر بأرض الوساوس - شانون برودي، عاملة صيدلية.

يبدو مفارقاً، بل غرائبياً، أن تُهرع لقصيدة ت س إليوت (الأرض الخراب) كي تعينك على فهم استلهام عبد العزيز بركة ساكن لها في كتابة روايته القصيرة، الرجل الخراب. فالمفارقة هي أن القصيدة المكتوبة في 1922، وبما عُرف عنها من تعقيد ووعورة، تحتاج هي نفسها لعشرات الشروحات، لكونها مغرقة في الإحالات لتواريخ وثقافات وأديان، بل ولغات أخرى غير لغتها الانجل…

وجوه أخرى للنباتات

وجوه اخرى للنباتات
قصة قصيرة
عندو عود كدا، قال مخصوص، ساط بيهو العلبة لما اخلاقي ضاقت. بعد داك قام قفلا. وقعد يلعب بي شوية الدقن ال عندو قلت ليهو شنو يا استاذ انا ما راجي آخد لي سفه من صنع يديك المدهش. ولا عاين لي ذاتو. قال لي شوية كدا. قمت بزعل خفيض سالتو شنو يعني. الساينص شنو هنا؟ قال لي مافي ساينص. هنا حكمة شعبية. رفعت صوتي شوية وقلت ليهو ياخي انا عايز سفه من غير حكمة شعبية. رد علي بازدرا واضح ما انتو ال بتبوظو الكوالتي باستعجالكم دا. سكتّ افكر. كلامو نوعا صاح وبعدين لقيت في ذهني استهانه بالمادة قيد المناكفه ذات نفسها. وسمعت جواي صوت بيقول لانو المادة دي اسمها سعوط فهي ما ممكن الزول يتحدث عن كواليتي ليها. قام هو فاجاني وقال لي عشان سعوط؟ ياخي النباتات دي كل واحدة ليها شخصيتها وبتتوقع انك تعاملها بالطريقة ال بتحبها عشان تديك العايزو. قلت ليهو يا استاذ شحتفت روحي ياخ. كلها سفه ونخلص. وبعد اتفها عندي سيجارة ح اشربا وكاسين. عاين لي كداااا وقال لي شنو البشتنه المتلاحقة دي. قلت ليهو متلاحقة متلاحقة. قام فاجاني بالكلام دا قال لي افتح العلبة وسف. قمت خفت وقعدت ساكت اعاين ليهو قام ضحك خشخشه ك…